No Need to Fear AI: We’ve Been Here Before

Recently, I watched a TVO documentary featuring Canadian actor and comedian Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll, who was struggling with the possibility that artificial intelligence might eventually replace him in the profession he loves.

I understood his concern.

After all, when you’ve spent years developing your skills, building a career, and doing something you’re passionate about, the idea that a machine might suddenly do the same work is unsettling.

But as I watched, I found myself wishing I could tell him something.

We’ve been here before. Many, many times.

And sometimes, the very technology we fear turns out to be the technology that opens doors we never dreamed possible.

When Publishing a Book Was Beyond My Reach

Back in the very early ’90s, while continuing my family history research, I wanted to know what it might cost to publish approximately 100 pages of my findings in a book.

I approached a local publisher for an estimate.

Ten thousand dollars!

That was the starting price.

For someone like me, that might as well have been a million dollars. I simply couldn’t afford it.

But something remarkable happened.

Not even two years later, I was learning desktop publishing, beginning with DOS 3 and quickly progressing to Windows 3.1.

Suddenly, publishing wasn’t something that required handing thousands of dollars to a professional publishing company.

I could learn to do much of the work myself.

I could arrange pages, format text, work with images, and prepare documents using a computer that initially was supplied by my school.

Did I know everything when I started?

Heavens, no!

But I was willing to learn.

And that willingness changed what was possible for me.

Technology hadn’t taken away my ambition to publish. It had given me a way to pursue it.

Imagine if I’d been so frightened of computers replacing traditional publishing methods that I’d refused to learn desktop publishing.

What opportunities might I have missed?

Think About the Horse and Buggy

There was a time when owning a horse was a considerable responsibility.

You needed somewhere to keep it. You had to feed it, groom it, care for its health, and arrange for someone to look after it when you were away.

Then along came the automobile.

Of course, early automobiles weren’t inexpensive or trouble-free. But as manufacturing improved, cars became increasingly practical and accessible.

An entire way of life changed.

Some occupations declined. Others emerged.

Mechanics, automobile manufacturers, service stations, driving instructors, and countless related businesses became part of everyday life.

And over time, industrialization helped expand the middle class, making a higher standard of living possible for more people.

We didn’t simply exchange horses for cars.

We developed an entirely different transportation industry.

And while that transformation undoubtedly created hardships for people whose livelihoods depended on horses, few of us today would want to return to relying on them for everyday transportation.

Then There Were Telegrams

Imagine needing to send an urgent message to someone hundreds of miles away.

For many years, the telegraph offered a remarkable solution, although sending messages could be expensive, particularly when charges depended on the number of words.

Then the telephone developed into a practical way for ordinary people to communicate directly.

No more composing abbreviated messages and paying someone to transmit them.

You could actually speak to another person.

Eventually, telephones became commonplace in homes.

And today?

We can communicate with someone on the other side of the world almost instantly, often at a fraction of what such communication once cost.

Each innovation changed the way people worked, communicated, and conducted business.

The technology changed. The human need remained.

Now It’s Artificial Intelligence

Rodrigo’s documentary made something very clear to me.

His greatest concern wasn’t simply losing a job.

He loves acting. He loves the creative process. He loves collaborating with other people.

And he’s frightened that AI-generated performances might take those experiences away from him.

I can understand that.

But I kept thinking about the possibilities he might be overlooking.

What if he learned to use AI to develop his own projects?

What if he could experiment with storylines, visualize scenes, develop characters, or create promotional material without needing a Hollywood-sized budget?

What if he could use the technology to reach audiences that might otherwise never discover his work?

He’s an actor and comedian. He already possesses the imagination, performance skills, and experience that make his work uniquely his.

AI could become another tool in his creative toolbox.

Not a replacement for his talent.

An opportunity to make more of it.

Of course, the entertainment industry’s concerns about performers’ likenesses, voices, compensation, and employment are legitimate.

They deserve serious attention and meaningful protections.

But refusing to explore a technology doesn’t prevent that technology from developing.

And it may mean missing opportunities that could make a real difference.

Something in the Documentary Made Me Smile

One of the people Rodrigo interviewed was futurist and technology educator Sinead Bovell.

She compared artificial intelligence to electricity.

Now, there’s an interesting comparison!

Electricity changed practically everything about how we lived and worked.

It took time for people to understand it, develop safeguards, and discover all the ways it could improve their lives.

Today, we barely give it a second thought.

We just expect it to be there when we flip a switch.

Could AI eventually become something equally ordinary?

Perhaps.

What I particularly appreciated about Sinead’s perspective was her encouragement to become familiar with the technology rather than feeling powerless in the face of it.

That’s a message I wholeheartedly agree with.

AI Isn’t Perfect. Neither Were the Technologies Before It.

Artificial intelligence can make mistakes.

It can produce convincing information that isn’t true. It can be misused. It raises legitimate concerns about privacy, copyright, employment, and our growing reliance on technology.

I certainly wouldn’t recommend accepting everything an AI system tells you without questioning it.

And we shouldn’t ignore the people whose jobs may be displaced.

History has shown us that technological progress can create opportunities while also causing genuine hardship.

But surely the answer isn’t to stop learning?

Perhaps the better approach is to understand these tools, challenge their shortcomings, insist on reasonable safeguards, and discover where they can genuinely improve our lives.

We don’t have to surrender our judgment to benefit from technology.

What If I’d Been Afraid?

I keep returning to that original $10,000 publishing estimate.

Had desktop publishing not become available, I might never have discovered just how much I could accomplish on my own.

Learning those programs required patience, curiosity, and plenty of trial and error.

But each new skill opened another door.

Today, artificial intelligence offers another opportunity to learn.

Will it change jobs?

Absolutely.

Will some jobs disappear?

Quite possibly.

Will new opportunities emerge that we haven’t even imagined yet?

I believe they will.

Think about it this way…

Consider someone like Bruce Willis, whose acting career was cut short by an illness that took him away from the work he loved.

What if AI could allow a younger version of Bruce to appear in future movies, provided such performances were consistent with his wishes and properly authorized?

His remarkable legacy might continue generating income that could contribute toward the expenses of his ongoing care, even though he can no longer perform.

Imagine the possibilities for other performers facing similar circumstances.

And that’s why I don’t look at AI as something to fear.

I look at it much the same way I once looked at that computer running DOS.

Something new.

Something unfamiliar.

Something worth learning.

Because the greatest opportunities often begin when we’re willing to say:

“I wonder what I could do with that?”

Here’s something you might find interesting.

Artificial intelligence helped me write this very article!

The experiences, memories, opinions, and message are mine. But AI helped me organize my thoughts, develop my ideas, and polish my writing.

It didn’t replace my creativity. It helped me express it.

After all, isn’t that exactly what I’ve been talking about?

I’d much rather discover what is possible than spend my time being frightened of what might happen.

Wouldn’t you?


Watch the documentary: Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll explores his concerns about artificial intelligence on TVO: https://www.tvo.org/video/documentaries/ai.

 
Images Credit: Created using ChatGPT

Trish

Given my passion for genealogy, is it any wonder that I eventually wanted to publish my work? Learning to use a personal computer was a natural step once I was introduced it in the 1990s. Then the internet offered a second means to "publish" and now, here I am with a personal blog.

Leave a Comment